Dear Eva,

I think we can have a discussion over Hindi films. Finally they give us bread and butter(Roji Roti )but apart from that what Hindi films give us? Does it give meaningful entertainment? Please think about bigger Picture.
We like Hindi films because its our own language..
Think about these points.

1 What Hindi films offer to International audience? ??
Do Hindi films take cinema language to a new height???
Every day we are getting technically better but what about Content??


2 We started making films from 1912-13. But why did very few films interests European or American audinece?

(Your counter argument might be our sensibilies are different then Western people. But all of us are not humans??



Lot of Hollywood Studios are coming to India to make collaberation but it's only for the market. They will exploit our resources... talents..But they can't generate good script which are within Indian soil.

3 . Young directors .. Vishal Bhardwaj, Ashutosh Govarikar, Anurag kashyap ,
can they compete against Wong Kar Wai (chinese Director) , Ang Lee( Taiwanne) , Majidi ( Iranian) Mahakalaf (Iranian) Lars Von Trier(Dutch) and Spike Lee (American ) , Inaritu ( Mexico)

4 In last five years couple of nice Hindi films came but any films are top notch films like Amerros Perros/ Departed/ Talk to Her/ Hunger?

5. I saw Dev D and Gulal. Dev D lacks the rhythm.. Gulal is full of over acting. They were nice films but didn't leave long lasting impression?

Love Peace Light
Your Sincerly
Janantik Shukla